EQUATORIAL MARGIN

Oil exploration is safe for marine life in the Amazon

ANALYSIS – This is what PhD Professor of Geology and Marine Geophysics, Alberto Figueiredo, guarantees. According to the researcher, there are no coral reefs on the Amazon coast as environmentalists maintain. It’s just “dead algae”, Affirms Alberto

Fabrício Queiroz / Especial para O Liberal

Translated by Silvia Benchimol and Ewerton Branco (ET-Multi-UFPA)

27/10/2023

By mid-19th century, the use of oil as an energy source caused a paradigm shift for the industry of the time. Two centuries later, the so-called "black gold" continues to be strategic for productive activities, but also for the sovereignty and security of countries. This importance has motivated the search for new reserves of natural fossil resources, which have led, for example, to the exploration of offshore wells. Today, attention has turned to the potential of a new frontier known as the Equatorial Margin.

Brazil is still trying to develop and deepen knowledge about the four sedimentary basins that extend for around 2,200 kilometers, from the State of Amapá, in the North Region, to the State of Rio Grande do Norte, in the Northeast. The idea of investigating the true potential of gas and oil wells is part of Petrobras planning, which foresees an investment of US$3 billion in this region by 2027.

The kickoff of this megaproject would take place in the Amazon region, with the exploration of the Morpho well, located in block FZA-M-59, at the mouth of the Amazon river basin, approximately 175 kilometers off the coast of Amapá. The area was purchased by British Petroleum (BP) and Petrobras at an auction in 2013, and, since then, has been at the center of intense technical, political and even scientific debate. One of the reasons for the controversy is the supposed existence of coral reefs known as Grande Sistema Recifal do Amazonas [Great Amazon Reef System – GARS] according to an article published by a group of more than 30 researchers in the magazine "Science Advances", in 2016.

Brazil is still trying to develop and deepen knowledge about the four sedimentary basins that extend for around 2,200 kilometers, from the State of Amapá, in the North Region, to the State of Rio Grande do Norte, in the Northeast
Brazil is still trying to develop and deepen knowledge about the four sedimentary basins that extend for around 2,200 kilometers, from the State of Amapá, in the North Region, to the State of Rio Grande do Norte, in the Northeast. (Disclosure)

The description of the marine ecosystem drew attention to the lack of knowledge about these organisms and the need for their preservation, which were the motto of several campaigns by a Canadian environmental Non-Governmental Organization (NGO). Questions about the risks of the venture combined with the slowness of the licensing process ended up by keeping BP away from the business, which was fully taken over by the Brazilian oil company and still does not have an exploration license, even after ten years.

Algae

Impact studies involve several measures to mitigate the well's biological, environmental and social risks, but corals are still among the main topics. Scientists who defend the existence of GARS maintain that the marine habitat is sensitive to the possible exploration and dispersion of oil.

On the other hand, there are researchers who dispute the data on the characteristics and vulnerability of GARS in the context of possible oil activity in the Amazon. Professor Alberto Figueiredo from Universidade Federal Fluminense (UFF) and doctor in Geology and Marine Geophysics, says that the targeted organisms would be “dead algae” and that there is nothing exceptional about their presence in the region.

“The majority are very old, up to 17 thousand years old. Among these algae you can find one or another living individual, but it does not correspond to the propagated exuberance. These calcareous algae are generally placed on the shelf edge. They extend throughout the Caribbean, the mouth of the Amazon river and reach the coast of the State of Santa Catarina (in southern Brazil). So, they are even found in other regions where there is oil production, such as Campos (in Rio de Janeiro) and Santos (in São Paulo) basins, where the existence of these calcareous algae is even greater than in the North of Brazil”, Figueiredo argues.

Study

Furthermore, according to the professor who is the author of an article entitled Mitos e verdades sobre os ‘corais da Amazônia’ [Myths and truths about ‘Amazonian corals’], the beings found cannot be named as such, as they would need to have access to light to be characterized as corals. Another important factor is that there is no reef construction, as claimed by other scientists.

“In the past, when sea levels were lower, these calcareous algae flourished and developed. As the sea level rose, the Amazon River also brought a lot of sediment, so very few or rare algae remain alive. And about corals, it’s hardly worth mentioning. You may find some corals, but they are not reef builders. So, in fact, what we have are slabs of carbonates formed by calcareous algae”, reinforces the professor.

“An international NGO started posting several images in the media and promoting effective marketing about the existence of corals at the mouth of the Amazon and I believe they are using images from the Caribbean because waters are clear. I felt indignant as a connoisseur of the region”, adds Alberto.

# See some highlights of the Brazilian Equatorial Margin project:

- Petrobras is expected to invest around US$3 billion from 2023 to 2027.

-16 wells will be drilled in four sedimentary basins: mouth of the Amazon (six blocks), Pará-Maranhão (two blocks), Barreirinhas (five blocks) and Potiguar (three blocks).

Potential of Pará-Maranhão basin is up to 30 billion barrels of oil

The academic debate is just one of the elements of a story of uncertainties and expectations. The forecasts are encouraging for the area, as oil reserves have been discovered in different locations on the continental margins that surround the Atlantic Ocean, including neighboring countries in South America and others in West Africa.

On a technical note, Allan Kardec Barros, professor at the Federal University of Maranhão (UFMA); Ronaldo Carmona, professor at the Escola Superior de Guerra; and Pedro Zalán, an oil exploration consultant, argue that, from a geological point of view, the African margins are similar to the Brazilian ones and, therefore, the same oil conditions that exist there would be replicated here.

The researchers estimate that the potential of the Pará-Maranhão basin alone would be in the order of 20 to 30 billion barrels of crude oil. Comparatively, the Campos and Santos basins have confirmed reserves and contingents of 40 billion barrels of oil. The plans of Petrobras include the Pará-Maranhão basin and three other sites located on the coast – Mouth of the Amazons, Barreirinhas and Potiguar. According to the company, 16 wells would be drilled over the next five years and would help the country's energy security and sovereignty in the context of the search for clean energy sources.

Transition

According to Ph.D. Alberto Figueiredo, investment in fossil fuels is necessary for the energy transition, especially considering that the production capacity of pre-salt reserves will begin to decline from the next decade onwards. He emphasizes that even cleaner matrices have problems and that the technological solutions found by Brazil make exploration safer compared to countries where coal is burned or oil is cracked.

“It has to be a gradual change, over time. We are not yet prepared for this radical change as proclaimed, as if a switch could be turned off and we would start using a new type of energy. We have to live with fossil fuels for a long time until we switch to new types of energy”, he analyzes. (F.Q.)

Learn more

Interest in the Equatorial Margin is not new, but it became more evident with the discoveries of oil and gas deposits in countries neighboring Brazil that also share territories in the area. In the last eight years, Colombia, Trinidad and Tobago, Guyana, Suriname and French Guiana have already found 92 reserves on the Equatorial Margin. Among them, the main exponent is Guyana, with 42 oil and gas discoveries and an estimated production of 360 thousand barrels per day, which made government revenue reach US$ 1 billion last year. Projections indicate that the country should accumulate US$157 billion by 2040.

# Check out the exploratory activities on the Equatorial Margin:

- Brazil: an oil and gas well in Rio Grande do Norte.

- Colombia: eleven exploratory wells and eight gas discoveries.

- Trinidad and Tobago: 37 exploratory wells and 21 oil and gas discoveries.

- Guyana: 64 exploratory wells and 42 oil and gas discoveries.

- Suriname: 40 exploratory wells and 19 oil and gas discoveries.

- French Guiana: seven exploratory wells and two oil discoveries.

SOURCE: PETROBRAS

Lack of environmental licensing stops project

Among the projects in the Brazilian Equatorial Margin, the most advanced one is in the Amazon River mouth. However, since Petrobras fully controlled block FZA-M-59 in 2021, a license to carry out the “Avaliação Pré-Operacional (APO) [Pre-Operational Assessment] in the Poço Morpho has not been issued yet. During the APO, the company's ability to respond to an oil spill event during operations would be assessed."

The estimate was that the simulation would take place in the first quarter of this year, after the Secretaria de Estado de Meio Ambiente e Sustentabilidade (Semas) [State Secretariat for the Environment and Sustainability] released the Centro de Reabilitação de Despetrolização da Fauna [Fauna Depetrolization Rehabilitation Center], located in the district of Icoaraci, in Belém. However, the Instituto Brasileiro do Meio Ambiente e dos Recursos Naturais Renováveis (Ibama) [Environment and Renewable Natural Resources Brazilian Institute] denied the license and requested the adoption of more measures to contain socio-environmental damage.

Sources related to oil sector informed Liberal Group that Petrobras has already presented solutions to all of the environmental agency's demands, which would be as follows: review of the study on the impact of the aircraft route on indigenous communities; the expansion of the emergency and fauna protection plan, with the creation of a support unit in the municipality of Oiapoque (AP); and the contesting to the requirement to carry out the procedure entitled “Avaliação Ambiental de Área Sedimentar” (AAAS) [Environmental Assessment of Sedimentary Areas], which, according to the Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF) [Federal Supreme Court], is unnecessary in this process. Petrobras has been awaiting a response to the request for reconsideration since last May.

Reactions

In the midst of this conflict, representatives of the productive sector in Pará and Amapá – states directly related to Poço Morpho operations – await a solution to the impasse in favor of the interest for regional development.

“As citizens of the Amazon, we cannot accept a plan that deprives us of knowledge about what we are giving up. Amazonian society cannot continue to be treated as a secondary actor regarding decisions that affect the region”, highlights the president of the Federação das Indústrias do Estado do Pará (Fiepa) [Federation of Industries of the State of Pará], Alex Carvalho, in a public note released after the recent release of exploration of blocks BM-POT-17 and POT-M-762, in the Potiguar Basin, on the coast of Rio Grande do Norte, where the company maintains its only active well in the Equatorial Margin.

Alex Carvalho, president of Fiepa: Amazon society must be consulted on decisions involving the project
Alex Carvalho, president of Fiepa: Amazon society must be consulted on decisions involving the project (Fiepa)

On the other hand, the president of the Sindicato da Indústria da Construção do Estado do Amapá [Construction Industry Union of the State of Amapá], Glauco Cei, highlights Petrobras' diligence in offshore projects and, therefore, states there is no justification for denials, other than related to political issues or attempts to favor economic segments from other regions to the detriment of the North.

“There is technology to contain any type of environmental damage that may occur. Why all this concern only on the coast of Amapá? Petrobras has an excellent reputation in terms of exploration while preserving the environment. So, this is not justified. We believe that this work developed by Petrobras will bring many benefits to the region, to Amapá and Pará”, points out the businessman.

"Oil and gas exploration will bring royalties", says the president of the Sindicato da Indústria da Construção do Estado do Amapá, Glauco Cei.  (Weslei Abreu / Rede Amazônica)

Glauco also reports the expectation of a transformation in the profile of the local economy with the advancement of the Equatorial Margin, as well as improvement of transport and logistics infrastructure in the State, with the implementation of regular airlines between Macapá, the capital of Amapá, and Oiapoque (municipality of Amapá) and the paving of the BR-156 highway, which connects the capital to the far north.

“The profile of the Amapá economy today is that we depend on paychecks and we need to have minimun autonomy. The exploration of oil and gas will bring royalties, it will bring benefits to the supporting regions, it will bring qualitative migration and better training for local companies”, says Glauco, who hopes that the Amazon region could reach the same level of growth observed in other locations where this activity was permitted.

“We cannot let other organizations from outside decide what our region should do. What we need to discuss better is our destiny and what we want for ourselves because those who know what the Amazon is are those who live in it and not people who imagine or fantasize or create a dream about the Amazon. I am very afraid of the transformation of the Amazon into a large zoo for human beings, we are the ones who live here. We can't let that happen. We need decision-making power”, he emphasizes.