mudas para refolrestamento - Marco Santos  Ag. Pará.jpg
SUITABLE MODEL

Economic transition in the Amazon demands attention to local challenges

Researchers defend that the process should respect the reality of the region. Investments in infrastructure are necessary

Camila Azevedo

Translated by Moacir Moraes Filho; Silvia Benchimol and Ewerton Branco (ET-Multi/UFPA)

15/02/2024

The current discussions on the Amazon do not involve only the need to preserve and rebuild the forest. Beyond that, the economic transition in the region has also been a hot topic of debates, even in the international scenario, as there is an understanding that the biome’s current income production model is one of the main generators of the present environmental crisis in the area. However, the alternatives regarding the best ways to move forward with the project divide opinions in the segments of local economy and among researchers of the topic.

In Pará, the concern of the sectors responsible for turning the economy around is leveraging the appropriate infrastructure so that the economic transition benefits reach everyone. Undoubtfully, the territory has potential for this. Research conducted by the Núcleo de Altos Estudos Amazônicos (NAEA) [Amazon High Studies Nucleus], from the Federal University of Pará (UFPA), points out that the potential of Pará of converting the financial standard is great and capable, as already happens, of injecting more than R$11 billion on the national Gross Domestic Product (GDP) just by using the three main products found in the forest – such as açaí.

plantação deles, de priprioca, pataqueira e estoraque - ft - Mariana Almeida  Cabron Studios (3).jpg
According to the research “Changes in the Global Value of Ecosystem Services”, the Preserved Amazon Forest through bioeconomy may generate up to R$7 trillion per year (Image: Mariana Almeida/ Cabron Studios)

In 2021, the year of the most recent GDP calculation, Pará had a 2.9% share in Brazil's economy, reaching R$262.9 billion. The data are from the Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE) [Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics]. In the North, the total contribution was R$564.064 billion and Pará was responsible for 46.2% of this value, thus maintaining 1st place in the region. The municipality of Parauapebas, in the southeast of Pará, has the largest GDP. As for the sectors with the most participation in the economic scenario, services, industry, public administration, and agriculture are highlights.

And the numbers can be improved. According to the research “Changes in the Global Value of Ecosystem Services”, the Amazon Forest preserved through the bioeconomy can generate up to R$7 trillion per year. In Pará, the study “Bioeconomy of Sociobiodiversity” estimated a potential for growth in value chains that could generate R$170 billion by 2040. These surveys appear in a state action plan, which also provides the necessary guidelines to achieve the goals, including investment in research and infrastructure.

Environmental Issues must outstand

The concept of economic transition can be understood as the transformation from a model that values more the mechanical and chemical standards of processes in relation to one that puts the environment in the spotlight. Professor Francisco de Assis, a researcher at Naea, explains that the models adopted for this change often consider realities that are different from those experienced in the Amazon, such as those developed in European countries and the United States. According to him, this creates crises in the application of solutions that could, in fact, be beneficial.

“When we talk about transition, we talk about low CO2, precision mechanization, computer-controlled tractors. This is an important tool in other realities, but in ours, it is different: the fact of having to create the lands, since they do not exist. They are not prepared for this economy to exist. They had to precede an act and that is the problem: deforestation. The Amazon's participation in the environmental crisis has to do with this, it must be addressed and not just say that the transition will follow the protocol of the European transition or the low carbon economy”, emphasizes the professor.

Land market

Francisco says that the transformation of public lands into private ones, carried out illegally and configuring what has been called the land market, could be listed among the main problems found in the Amazon region – and that needs urgent combat. Added to the fact that this practice also generates deforestation, the researcher states that the sector, despite being linked to different parts of the economy – such as soybeans and livestock farming –, has the autonomy to operate within the territories. “This market appropriates lands with forests, cuts the forests down and sells the lands”.

_PROFESSOR DOUTOR FRANCISCO DE ASSIS COSTA  - cristino martins(45).JPG
“This market appropriates lands with forests, cuts the forests down and sells the lands”, says the professor Francisco de Assis (Image: Cristino Martins/O Liberal)

“Despite being a very complex process from an institutional point of view, it has many important sensitive variables, but the central thing for us to have is this, here in the Amazon is still the place in the country where the land market functions as a subsector that produces land. They kill and produce new lands. So, I don't see how to create a transition economy, in which the notion of transition effectively applies to the Amazon. In other words, stops the process of forest destruction, acts on deforestation, without dealing with these land production mechanisms in a determined, serious and profound way”, he states.

Bioecological bioeconomy may be the solution

The studies carried out by Naea move in a direction that states the bioecological bioeconomy, a production model that already exists in the Amazonian territory, can be an effective solution to the problems found in the environment. According to Francisco de Assis, the logic changes: from valuing mechanical processes, the practice enhances the preservation of nature. “This bioecological economy is, in fact, what our peasants, ancestors, indigenous people do. You have this gigantic family production associated with the Amazon biome”, highlights the researcher.

According to a survey by Naea, this economy involves, throughout the Amazon, 400 thousand establishments and around 1 million workers. The sectors are the most diverse: from açaí production – 80% of the fruit comes from this model – to pharmaceutical manipulation. In the scenario, as a whole, the state of Pará has the best organized structure. “The technique works because people have been doing this for 300 years, based on technologies as well. But they are technologies of other types, in which these life structures [the biome] are at the center of the processing”, says Francisco.

Therefore, the researcher considers that the economic transition in the Amazon must begin by valuing the existing sustainable production model and must not exclude itself. On the contrary, it is interesting to have exchanges between all sectors. “The transition, here, is something else: it is valuing, it is recognizing the existence, and it starts there, designing effective public policies for this economy. This knowledge is ancestral, but it does not mean that it needs to be excluded. It can connect with the laboratory's knowledge, actually be integrated to the research and dialog with them”, he adds.

Challenges for the industry

In Pará, the industrial sector has invested in agro-industries. According to the Federation of Industries of the State of Pará (Fiepa), Santo Antônio do Tauá, Moju and Abaetetuba are examples of cities that are putting sustainable techniques into practice so that the economic transition in the Amazon becomes a reality. However, Alex Carvalho, president of the entity, states that better infrastructure is needed in the region to transport products and promote competitiveness.

“It will also bring the necessary security so that legal and formal activity to be established. The Amazon, from a time when environmental awareness has become increasingly relevant, has attracted many investments, and has been a region with great potential for growth. When we talk about bioeconomy, we are clearly talking about the extreme potential of the largest biodiversity forest on the planet. If we have these resources. If we have this availability, we have the origin. We need to improve the means a lot, so that the end is desirable”, adds Alex.

Along with infrastructure, the president of Fiepa argues that the industry should seek to decarbonize the sector and increase investments in the modernization of the industrial park, as a way of leveraging efforts for the transition. “And qualify the workforce well. A third link is for the industry to be more inclusive. Pará has great models of socio-environmental inclusion. The potential we have is huge, so we have a great chance to first step out of informality, to stop having that activity that is eminently extractive or without scalability, to a rational scale.”

20240218TRANSICAOECONOMICA - joão de barros- crpedito - ALEX CARVALHO.jpg
The president of Fiepa, Alex Carvalho, defends that the industry seeks to decarbonize the sector and increase investments in the modernization of the industrial park (Image: João Barros/ FIEPA)

Obstacles

One of the biggest obstacles to an economic transition that benefits the industrial sector in the Amazon is still the fight against illegal mining. Alex states that the clandestinity found in the region gives the image that there is no urgency to also deal with climate issues. However, the reality is the opposite. “Clandestine activities are bringing this villainy, and we are against illegality. We are in favor of formalizing legal activity, so that there are conditions to bring competitiveness to our product, as well as lower the cost of those who control and monitor illegalities”, he guarantees.

Employment

Currently, in Pará, the industrial sector employs 198 thousand people, according to Fiepa. With economic transition initiatives being put into practice, the estimate is that this number will make a positive jump. “The bioeconomy is shedding a light on ideas and model concepts. Industry is employment. We have the potential to bring longevity to this added value, to bring a long flight of jobs with dignity, formal employment, access to education, health and well-being. We have the opportunity to move from a level of very low GDP per capita to make a significant leap”, he concludes.

Technology is an ally of the agricultural sector

One of the allies used by the agricultural sector in the Amazon region to guarantee an effective economic transition is technology. Pará has the second largest herd of cattle – bovines and buffaloes – in Brazil and has gained prominence in cheese production. This scenario is concentrating a series of efforts, according to Guilherme Minssen, zootechnician and director of the Federation of Agriculture and Livestock of Pará (Faepa), to monitor the transitions that the current situation of the climate crisis has required. “In this transition, Pará is a model of genetics, nutrition and sanity.”

pecuária - divulgaçao - ag pará.jpg
“In this transition, Pará is a model of genetics, nutrition and sanity”, says Guilherme Minssen, zootechnician and director of Faepa (Image: Ag. Pará)

“On the genetic side, we have improved animals. In the past, they went to slaughter when they were two years old. Today, at 20 months, they are already being slaughtered. In other words, precocity. We genetically evolve our herds. This is one of the great weapons we use in this bioeconomy. We also produce more and in a smaller area because of nutrition. We have pastures in smaller areas with nutritional quality, both in protein and energy. Furthermore, we have improved vaccination techniques. We have areas that are free from foot-and-mouth disease without vaccination and, as a result, our cattle are at very low risk. This is our tripod”, he lists.

Guilherme Minssen, da Faepa - arquivo pessoal (2)1.jpg
The scenario is concentrating a series of efforts, according to Guilherme Minssen, zootechnician and director of the Federation of Agriculture and Livestock of Pará (Faepa), to monitor the transitions that the current situation of the climate crisis has required (Image: Personal file)

Community sees a way to change its reality

The opening of an agribusiness focused on the extraction of natural oils by residents of Campo Limpo, community of Santo Antônio do Tauá, in the northeast of Pará, is considered a step towards the economic transition in the Amazon. The initiative is in partnership with a cosmetics company. Dilma Lopes, 54 years old, is president of the Association of Rural Producers (Aprocamp) and says that reality has been transformed through this work. “Our parents worked in the farms to survive and support the family.”

plantação deles, de priprioca, pataqueira e estoraque - ft - Mariana Almeida  Cabron Studios (4).jpg
The opening of an agribusiness focused on the extraction of natural oils by residents of Campo Limpo, community of Santo Antônio do Tauá, in the northeast of Pará, is considered a step towards the economic transition in the Amazon (Image:  Mariana Almeida/Cabron Studios)

Before, the community grew vegetables. Today, the economy relies on the introduction of priprioca, pataqueira and storax, used for oil extraction. “This change of life led us to preserve. Before, when our parents worked in the farms, we had to deforest a place to do the work, that was how it was maintained. Agroindustry was precisely about generating income. We were very poor, our dreams couldn't be realized just with the farm. Now, young people don’t go out to look for resources abroad, they see the possibility of income within our community.”